For What It's Worth Wisdom and Insight from the Auto Appraisal Group

Common Vintage Vehicle ScamsThanks to the internet and websites like Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace, it has never been easier to buy or sell a vehicle on the secondary market. Private car sales negotiated between individuals can be the source of great finds or nasty scams – high rewards are possible, but so are devastating losses. Avoiding these classic car scams is essential, and the best way to avoid them is to learn how to spot them.

Common Classic Car Selling Scams:

These are some common red flags that indicate your buyer may not be “on the level”:

Common Vintage Vehicle ScamsACH Transfer Fraud:

ACH transfers occur when money moves between banks electronically. You may be asked to provide account information or send money to your account. After a few days, the buyer claims the transfer was unauthorized and will attempt to keep your money AND your vehicle.

Fake Mobile Deposits:

The buyer might ask to log into your mobile banking app to deposit funds into your account, but instead of depositing money, they remove funds and put the money into their account instead. Never allow a buyer access to your banking information. It will never be necessary for them to access your bank account to send you payment.

Deferred Payments or Loans:

A buyer might ask you to wait until they receive a paycheck or a settlement payment, at which time they will pay in full. They may also ask for a loan on part of the amount. It should come as little surprise that they then disappear with the car. If a buyer wants a deferred payment, you should always keep the car until the payment is received in full, though we always suggest avoiding deferred payment situations.

Common Vintage Vehicle ScamsOverpayment:

This is a common scam in which the buyer sends a cashier’s check or money order for more than the agreed-upon price. In this scam, the buyer never sent a legitimate check or money order in the first place. When you are asked to send a refund on the overpayment, the buyer disappears with your money before you realize the original payment was illegitimate.

Tips for Selling Safely

You can protect yourself from these scams with a little extra care and caution.

  • Meet in a Safe Location: When meeting potential buyers, choose a public and well-lit location to conduct the transaction. Avoid secluded areas or inviting strangers to your home.
  • Bring a Friend: It’s always wise to have someone accompany you during the meeting with potential buyers. This provides an extra layer of security and can be helpful during negotiations.
  • Verify Buyer’s Identity: Ask to see the buyer’s driver’s license and jot down their information before allowing a test drive. This can help deter fraudulent activity and ensure accountability.
  • Take a Test Drive Together: Accompany the buyer on the test drive to ensure they handle the car responsibly and safely. Set clear boundaries and establish a predetermined route.
  • Secure Payment: Be sure that you only accept certified checks when selling, and consider an escrow account for buyers that are not in your area. An escrow account can reduce the risks of fraud and allow you to confirm that funds have cleared with the escrow service before you ship your vehicle.
  • Trust Your Instincts: If something feels off during the transaction or if the buyer exhibits suspicious behavior, trust your instincts and proceed with caution. Your safety and security are paramount.

Common Vintage Vehicle ScamsCommon Classic Car Buying Scams:

Watch for these scams when buying a vehicle:

Priced Below Market Value:

What you find generally is also true in car-buying: if it seems too good to be true, it probably is. Fraudsters will often post enticing pictures of exotic cars with prices that seem far too low. When you contact the scammer, they will tell you the car is actually out-of-state or even out of the country. They will then ask for money to ship the car – a car that most likely doesn’t exist.

False Escrow Services:

Escrow services are a legitimate way for sellers to protect money, but sellers can also lie and claim to use a fake escrow service in order to get you to transfer funds before the car can be shipped. The scammer will then break the contract once the funds clear. Using a legitimate and well-known escrow service is the best way to ensure your fund’s safety.

Pressure and Urgency:

A scammer will often pressure buyers to make a decision quickly, often causing them to overlook potential warning signs. They will say they have other buyers waiting, or they need to sell the vehicle quickly due to personal reasons. They may tell a buyer they don’t have time to wait for an escrow service, if they want the vehicle they have to put down a deposit NOW! Then they disappear with your money. Be cautious of sellers who use aggressive sales tactics or try to rush you into making a decision.

Common Vintage Vehicle ScamsBuying Sight Unseen:

It should be a giant red flag any time a seller expects you to buy a car without seeing it first! The seller may claim they are too busy to meet you, or they may even offer a fake inspection report to convince you that the car is in working order. In truth, the car may not even run – or exist – at all. We always advise against buying a car you have not seen in person. If the vehicle is out of state, get a pre-purchase inspector to view the vehicle for you.

Tips for Buying Safely:

You can protect yourself as a buyer by following a few simple steps.

  • Perform a Vehicle History Check: Ask for the VIN number and Google it to see where it comes up. If they refuse to give a VIN – Beware! Performing a vehicle history check can alert you to repairs, accidents, and other signs that the car may be a lemon. You can use any of the reputable services online, like CarFax, Auto Check, and Vin Check Pro to perform a history check; but know that they only know what is reported to them. Not everything gets reported. History reports do not show you the current condition and providers do not know the current value.
  • Check For Liens: It’s also a good idea to check for liens on the vehicle. Verify that the owner’s driver’s license matches the information on the car’s title, and visit the local DMV to find out about liens on the vehicle.
  • Research the Seller: If the seller is representing themselves as a dealer, confirm the dealer exists and you are actually communicating with the dealer. Google the phone number in the ad. Google the address and look at the location on Google Maps. If it shows a car lot, do you see similar vehicles to the one you’re pursuing? If no phone number, or no one ever answers the phone, and they communicate over email only – Beware! Legitimate dealerships want to talk with you.
  • Verify the Vehicle Condition: See the vehicle in person or get a pre-purchase inspection if an in-person inspection isn’t possible. Ask for additional photos or documentation to verify the legitimacy of the listing.
  • Secure Payment: Do not send deposits or payments if you have not verified the legitimacy of the vehicle. Avoid payment methods that offer little recourse for recovery, such as wire transfers, crypto, or gift cards. Using an escrow service is the safest way to ensure your funds are not released until after you receive the vehicle.
  • Trust Your Instincts: If something feels off or too good to be true, trust your instincts and proceed with caution. Don’t be pressured into making hasty decisions, and always err on the side of caution when dealing with unfamiliar sellers or listings.

Common Vintage Vehicle ScamsScammers count on buyers to be uneducated, and many scams rely on the ability to hide damage before the sale. This is especially true of vintage vehicles, whose value may depend on the use of OEM parts and original paint. It can be hard for the average buyer to spot the little differences that can cost thousands of dollars. The best way to protect yourself from paying more than you should is to have the car inspected.

How We Can Help

If you are considering buying a vintage vehicle locally or from a distance, a pre-purchase inspection from AAG can be a real lifesaver! A pre-purchase inspector can meet with the seller to prove the vehicle is real and as advertised. Scam sellers will avoid meeting in person or have something to hide about the vehicle, so insisting on a pre-purchase inspection can help determine if the sale is legitimate or not. AAG inspections have been instrumental in avoiding vintage vehicle scams for many of our clients and we are ready to help you too!